Follow
Share

My 54-year old sister has had substance abuse problems and I believe she has been diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder. She visited our 85-year old mother tonight. Mom has become more confused and forgetful so a few months ago we moved her from IL to AL. Anyway sis brought our mother a recording of songs sis had made to play. At our mother’s funeral. I don’t think I have ever been so angry. Our mother is, yes, aging rapidly but my siblings and our mother have not yet discussed funeral arrangements. My sister TOLD our mother about the songs she wants to play on her guitar at the memorial service. Am I wrong to be furious with my sister? My mother thought this treatment was rather harsh but in my opinion it was beyond harsh and just cruel.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Im not seeing the controversy here personally. Sounds like she’s being thoughtful and wanting to understand mom’s wishes for her funeral.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Well maybe now is the time to have that funeral planning discussion. Your mentally ill sister opened the door. Have the conversation. Your sister can’t help who she is so why be furious.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
AlvaDeer Dec 27, 2023
I was actually going to add to my response that this could be a good opportunity to say "By the way, what music WOULD you like. We should ALL have this written out, because any of us could cross the street forgetting to look both ways, but it is certainly true for those of us of a certain age." Sister has not the inhibitions we all have to stay "polite" at any cost. She is calling it like she sees it. I still cannot help finding this one a bit humorous. But then my brother and I always did own that we have the most perverse senses of humor we ever saw.
(4)
Report
Thank you everyone for your responses to my question. I have calmed down since I posted it. I may have inadvertently posted the same question twice as I was not sure the first went through. It is not easy to deal with our concerns about our elderly loved ones, is it? Have a good day with your loved ones no matter their age
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
AlvaDeer Dec 28, 2023
I'm so glad to hear this response.
It sure is complicated, dealing with our loved one.
As an 81 year old, tho, I can guarantee you we are sometimes not so fragile as we seem. I hope you can eventually kind of get a laugh out of this. Family memory album!
(2)
Report
I don't personally see anything wrong with what your sister did as we're all going to die some day and we should all be prepared with our final wishes.
You say your mom is 85 years old and has memory issues(more than likely some dementia)and yet no one has discussed any funeral arrangements. What are you waiting for? Wouldn't you rather make these plans now before her dementia gets worse?
Perhaps your reaction to your sisters sharing the music she wants to play at moms funeral stems more from the fact that you're just not ready to lose your mom yet, even though you know that time will be here before you know it.
Death is part of life and plans should be discussed with the family before it's too late.
So now that the door has been opened about moms funeral, it might be time to find out exactly what she would like when her time comes, so that you're honoring her wishes and no one else's.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

OMG, this--I am sooo sorry-----actually made me laugh.
I will tell you first of all that I am an old (81) retired RN, so as you can imagine, DEATH has always been a subject in my family's life. And one we sometimes laugh about. I am uncertain what else is to be done about that darned Grim Reaper stalking us all.
Then I'll plead my case by letting you know I have someone in my family with a personality disorder. And I can actually just SEEEEEE this. Or hear it which is more the case.
I want to find one-liners for response such as "Don't give up your day job" after the first tune is played.

It sounds a bit to me as though, of everyone involved here. your mom may have taken this better than anyone, as you describe her as finding this only a bit "harsh". I guess I would say "Well, THAT'S a surprise, my own private dirge written especially for my own funeral as a Christmas Present while I'm still alive and kicking!"

People write us on AC all the time about things that the demented say and do. And we always respond that "you are arguing with a disease" or "It's the disorder you are speaking with" and so on. And in this case, that is also true. Sister just is living in her her little world. For most with mental disorders it is just "me, me, me and me" all the time. Not "you are old and dying" but "Look! I just wrote a song". Not much to be done about that.

I am not certain what the proper response might have been, because clearly Sis likely meant well. But wow! Just wow.
You must forgive me, because death is such a commonplace for discussion that this year when I watched The Bishop's Wife yet again I said happily remarked to my daughter "Well, I am changing my epitaph from whatever I last chose to "Does This Mean I Can't Watch The Bishop's Wife Next Christmas"?
She, or someone else, replied "That's too long for a tombstone anyway".

I do honestly hope that this wasn't too distressing. It had to be awkward in a family that doens't discuss the subject much. I do think you all recognize how it came about and why, and all will get over it. I don't think, for CERTAIN, that it should be brought up with sister. The Holidays are always full of it, aren't they.

I wish you the best. Cruelty wasn't the goal here. So often it isn't. My best out to you. I hope no one choked on his or her egg nog, and that a good holidays (for the most part) was had by all.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
AmThereToo Jan 7, 2024
My Mom planned her funeral and everything down to the last eyelash after my step dad died (13+ years sgo). Now she is 91 with dementia, and it turns out to be one of the greatest gifts she has given us. Everyone dies. It's sad, but has to be "lived through" by those of us left behind. I think it is good to acknowledge, plan for and get out of the way so you can really LIVE the rest of your life.
(2)
Report
You know you can still love your sister for being your sister and not her brain disorder, right? I mean seriously your Mom still loves her.
You seem uptight. Maybe you and other 'siblings' need to go out and have a beer or something and chill out.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Personally I think more people should talk about what plans they want.
People should be involved in the planning of their funeral.
If this upset mom she could have asked sister to stop.
But now that the "Pandora's box" has been opened maybe it is time to plan and begin prepaying for the funeral. (I did this just this year, making payments, but discussing it at my daughter's house my granddaughter just looked at me and told me I was not allowed to die...I just chuckled and said there was not much I could do about that!)
I think preplanning takes a LOT of stress out of the situation and you are not pressured to make choices you would not normally make. And you can shop around for best prices. Funeral homes, at least in my area are very willing to give you a price list as to what is included in various "packages"
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Your sister seems to be looking ahead to the day when your mother dies and is expressing how she feels. She may not have meant any harm to your mother at all.

I am sorry that your sister has struggled with mental health and a substance abuse problem.

I wouldn’t stop her from visiting with your mother, unless her issues become a serious concern for you. Discussing songs isn’t a major issue.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think your sister was way out of line pulling such a stunt personally, but remember you're dealing with an addict who's mentally ill. Maybe she was trying to be purposely hurtful, or maybe she was trying to show how thoughtful she is in planning ahead for moms memorial service, who knows how an addled mind works? I probably would've escorted her sorry arse out the door had she done such a thing, but I have a bad temper from time to time under certain circumstances.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I don't think ur sister meant any harm. You are dealing with someone with a mental illness that may not realize where Mom is cognitive wise. Mom is not young and her Dementia could get worse quickly. It may be a subject you need to discuss before Mom gets worse.

Because of Medicaid, I took a small insurance policy Mom had to cash in and prepaid her funeral. Since we used the same Funeral Home she used for Dad, I went to them. I purchased the same coffin she got for Dad. Flowers we left for later as was the service and luncheon. It was so nice, not having to deal with it.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter